
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for an adults-only, intimate Old Town stay steps from Duval Street and historic sights.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an 18-room adults-only boutique inn in Old Town for travelers who want a small, historic-property experience within easy walking distance of Duval Street. Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection is a larger, historic oceanfront resort affiliated with Hilton’s Curio brand, aimed at guests who want beach access, more on-site facilities, and a branded upscale stay.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for an adults-only, intimate Old Town stay steps from Duval Street and historic sights.

Best for guests who prioritize private beach access, multiple pools, and full-service resort amenities under a Hilton Curio affiliation.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if you want an adults-only, small-property experience in restored cigar-maker cottages with a palm-shaded pool, a complimentary continental breakfast, and immediate Old Town walkability to bars, galleries, and historic homes.
When Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection wins: pick Casa Marina if you want oceanfront rooms, private beach access, two outdoor pools, a full-service spa, and the scale and services (business center, larger meeting spaces, on-site watersports) of a branded resort.
Bottom line: both properties share Key West character and historic ties, but they serve different needs — Paradise Inn for quiet, adult-focused Old Town lodging; Casa Marina for resort-style beach access and more on-site facilities under a major soft brand.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, quiet, historic cottages and gardens; adults-only. | Historic oceanfront resort with larger, resort-scale facilities and Hilton Curio affiliation. |
| Location | 819 Simonton Street in Old Town, about a block from Duval Street and close to Hemingway Home and the Lighthouse. | 1500 Reynolds Street on the oceanfront (Higgs Beach area), roughly 0.9 km from Duval Street. |
| Size (rooms) | About 18 rooms and suites across restored cottages and small buildings. | 311 rooms and suites (property listing). |
| Ages / admission | Adults-only property; minimum check-in age 21; guests 18 and under not permitted. | All-ages resort (not adults-only); standard hotel policies apply. |
| Pools & water | One palm-shaded outdoor pool with fountain feature and a separate outdoor hot tub. | Two outdoor pools and private beach access with beach sun loungers and umbrellas. |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and an evening wine-and-cheese happy hour are provided. | On-site restaurant (Morrison’s Market referenced) plus a bar/lounge and a beach bar; room service limited hours; full breakfasts available for a fee. |
| Spa & wellness | No dedicated spa facility; in-room massage available upon request and a small outdoor hot tub. | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments, and facials; fitness facilities and spa treatment rooms. |
| Known for | Historic, intimate adults-only lodging and immediate Old Town walkability. | Historic oceanfront property with private beach, multiple pools, and Curio/Hilton services. |
| Meetings & events | No named event/meeting spaces verified; property explicitly refuses certain group party bookings. | Conference space (about 976 m²) and seven meeting rooms listed on the supplier listing. |
| Parking & transport | On-site parking available (fee reported); no airport shuttle. | Self parking (surcharge) and valet parking (surcharge) listed; nearest airport is Key West Intl. (EYW). |
Paradise Inn sits in Old Town’s historic interior on Simonton Street, a short walk to Duval Street and many landmark sights.
Choose Paradise Inn if you want immediate Old Town access and short walks to historic attractions.
Casa Marina is an oceanfront resort on Reynolds Street with direct access to a private beach and resort grounds.
Choose Casa Marina if beachfront location and on-site beach time matter more than being in the core Old Town blocks.
Rooms at Paradise Inn are set in restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style buildings, emphasizing historic character.
Expect unique, cottage-style rooms with historic detail and a small-property feel.
Casa Marina offers a wide range of room types and oceanview suites across a large resort property.
Expect more standard hotel room variety, including true oceanfront suites and larger configurations.
Paradise Inn does not operate a named on-site restaurant or bar but provides daily complimentary continental breakfast and an evening poolside offering.
Good for travelers who plan to eat off-property in Old Town and want a light included breakfast.
Casa Marina runs on-site dining and beverage outlets, including a market-style option and a beach bar.
Better if you want on-site meals, a beachfront bar, or convenient resort dining.
Paradise Inn centers on a palm-shaded outdoor pool with a fountain feature and a separate outdoor hot tub.
Ideal if you prefer a small, relaxed pool area in an adults-only setting.
Casa Marina offers two outdoor pools plus a private stretch of beach and full beach services.
Better for guests who plan to spend significant time swimming, lounging by a pool, or on a private beach.
Paradise Inn keeps things low-key: tropical gardens, an outdoor hot tub, and optional in-room massages.
Pick Paradise Inn for a quieter, low-service wellness experience and evening calm.
Casa Marina has a full-service spa and fitness facilities alongside resort-level services and evening options.
Choose Casa Marina if you want a traditional resort spa and on-site activity options.

Paradise Inn — a block from Duval Street and steps from Hemingway Home and the Lighthouse.

Casa Marina — private beach, beach loungers/umbrellas, and oceanfront rooms.

Paradise Inn — strictly adults-only with quiet, cottage-style grounds.

Casa Marina — two pools, full-service spa, meeting rooms, and branded hotel services.
Casa Marina — it has a private beach and beach services, plus two pools; Paradise Inn is in Old Town without beachfront access.
No. Paradise Inn is adults-only with a minimum check-in age of 21 and does not permit guests 18 and under.
Yes. Casa Marina lists a full-service spa with massages, body treatments, and facials.
Paradise Inn is closer to the core Old Town attractions and Duval Street; Casa Marina is farther west on the oceanfront (about 0.8–0.9 km to Duval).
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·