
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for quiet, adults-only Old Town stays steps from Duval Street and historic sights.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an adults-only, 18-room boutique inn made up of restored cigar-maker cottages in Old Town—read this if you want a quiet, historic, adult-focused stay within easy walking distance of Duval Street. The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a modern, 4-star harbor-area resort with multiple pools and poolside dining—read this if you want polished design, more on-site facilities, and a harbor location.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for quiet, adults-only Old Town stays steps from Duval Street and historic sights.

Best for travelers who want a modern harbor-side resort with multiple pools, on-site dining, and a larger property footprint.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: Choose Paradise Inn if you want a small, adults-only property with historic charm, a palm-shaded pool and hot tub, complimentary continental breakfast, and immediate Old Town walkability.
When The Marker wins: Choose The Marker for a larger, contemporary resort experience—multiple outdoor pools, a poolside restaurant (Starboard), a fitness center, and rooms with private balconies, plus easy access to the Historic Seaport and marina.
Bottom line: If your priority is a quiet, intimate, adults-only Old Town base steeped in historic character, Paradise Inn is the better fit. If you prefer a modern harbor-side resort with more on-site amenities and pool energy, The Marker is the stronger pick.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic, intimate adults-only inn | Polished, modern harbor-area boutique resort |
| Location | 819 Simonton St, in Old Town one block from Duval Street | 200 William Street, steps from Key West Bight/ Historic Seaport |
| Size | 18 rooms (adults-only) | 96 rooms |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only; minimum check-in age 21 | All-ages property (not adults-only) |
| Pools | One palm-shaded outdoor pool plus separate hot tub | Three outdoor pools and one poolside bar/restaurant |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and a wine-and-cheese happy hour | On-site poolside restaurant Starboard, poolside bar, room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | Outdoor spa tub and in-room massage on request | Fitness facilities onsite; dedicated spa facility not published |
| Known for | Historic cigar-maker cottages, tropical gardens, quiet adult atmosphere | Harbor-front location, marina access, multiple pools |
| Parking | On-site parking (fee; limited spaces) | Self parking (surcharge); covered parking available |
| Near | Walking access to Duval Street, Hemingway Home, Lighthouse | Walking access to Key West Historic Seaport, Mallory Square, Sloppy Joe's |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in Old Town, a short walk to Duval Street and several historic attractions.
Pick Paradise Inn for immediate Old Town immersion and close pedestrian access to the island’s top historic sights.
The Marker sits on William Street at the Key West Bight/Historic Seaport with direct access to the harbor and marina area.
Choose The Marker if you want a harbor-front base with easy access to marina activities and the Historic Seaport.
Rooms at Paradise Inn are configured as suites and cottage-style accommodations in low-rise historic buildings.
If you value historic architecture, larger suite-style rooms, and private outdoor nooks, Paradise Inn delivers that cottage feel.
The Marker offers air-conditioned rooms with private balconies or patios and a range of classic and suite-style options.
Pick The Marker for contemporary rooms with private balconies and a wider set of room-type choices, including harbor views.
Paradise Inn does not operate a named on-site restaurant or bar but offers in-house breakfast and evening amenities.
If you want quiet evenings and walkable access to a wide variety of off-property dining, Paradise Inn fits well—there's no on-site restaurant.
The Marker has on-site dining and poolside service to keep more meals and drinks on property.
The Marker is better if you want on-site casual dining and poolside drink options without leaving the property.
Paradise Inn centers its outdoor life around a palm-shaded pool and a separate hot tub in a garden setting.
Choose Paradise Inn for a quieter, garden-shaded pool area suited to an adults-only atmosphere.
The Marker advertises several outdoor pool areas and poolside energy as a key part of the stay.
Pick The Marker if multiple pools and poolside dining are central to your idea of a resort stay.
Paradise Inn focuses on low-key wellness and Old Town evening strolls rather than a dedicated fitness or nightlife program.
If you want quiet relaxation and nearby evening options in Old Town without on-site nightlife, Paradise Inn matches that need.
The Marker provides fitness facilities and places guests close to the seaport’s active evening scene.
Choose The Marker for an active stay with on-site fitness and easy access to harbor-area evening activity.

Paradise Inn—historic cottages, palm-shaded pool and hot tub, and enforced adults-only policy.

The Marker—three outdoor pools, poolside bar, and a poolside restaurant keep most of the action on property.

The Marker—located at Key West Bight with immediate marina and seaport access.

Paradise Inn—central Old Town address and short walks to Hemingway Home, the Lighthouse, and Duval Street.
Paradise Inn is strictly adults-only (minimum check-in age 21). The Marker is an all-ages property and not adults-only.
The Marker operates an on-site poolside restaurant (Starboard) and a pool bar. Paradise Inn does not have a named restaurant or bar but provides complimentary continental breakfast and a wine-and-cheese happy hour.
The Marker sits at the Historic Seaport/Key West Bight and offers easy access to marina activities. Paradise Inn is in Old Town and can arrange excursions through concierge services, but it is not on the harbor.
The Marker has three outdoor pools. Paradise Inn has one outdoor pool plus a separate hot tub.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·