
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for adults wanting a quiet, historic-cottage stay steps from Duval Street with a small pool, hot tub, and cottage-style rooms.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an adults-only boutique inn made up of restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style suites for travelers who want a quiet, historic Old Town base. The Gardens Hotel is an upscale historic boutique hotel set in tropical gardens with more traditional hotel services — read this if you’re choosing between a small, private inn and a larger garden-focused boutique property in Old Town Key West.
Updated

Best for adults wanting a quiet, historic-cottage stay steps from Duval Street with a small pool, hot tub, and cottage-style rooms.

Best for travelers who want a larger boutique hotel with multiple pools, an on-site restaurant and bars, and traditional hotel services in a garden setting.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: Pick Paradise Inn if you want an adults-only, small-property experience in historic cottages, a palm-shaded pool and separate spa tub, and easy walkability to Old Town sights with more privacy and a calm evening atmosphere.
When The Gardens Hotel wins: Choose The Gardens Hotel if you prefer an upscale boutique hotel with more on-site facilities (two outdoor pools, a restaurant and poolside bar, concierge services, and formalized amenities) and don’t need an adults-only policy.
Bottom line: Both properties serve Old Town Key West visitors well but for different priorities — Paradise Inn for intimate, adults-only cottage charm; The Gardens Hotel for a full-service boutique hotel experience set among landscaped gardens.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | The Gardens Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, intimate adults-only inn in restored historic cottages | Upscale historic boutique hotel set amid tropical gardens |
| Location | Old Town, on Simonton Street, a short walk to Duval Street and major Old Town attractions | |
| Size (rooms) | About 18 rooms across multiple cottages and small buildings | 21 air-conditioned rooms (supplier listing) with multiple cottage and suite types |
| Age policy | Adults-only (minimum check-in age 21; guests under 18 not permitted) | Adults-only restriction appears in some supplier copy (guests under 16 not permitted); supplier metadata mixed — check property when booking |
| Pools & spa | One palm-shaded outdoor pool with fountain feature + separate outdoor hot tub (spa tub); in-room massage available on request | Two outdoor pools, poolside bar, and references to a health/beauty spa nearby or on-property services |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar (complimentary continental breakfast and wine & cheese happy hour provided) | On-site restaurant plus 2 bars/lounges and a poolside bar |
| Accessibility & services | Accessible King Mini Suite and wheelchair-accessible path of travel; no elevator; front-desk with limited hours | Wheelchair-accessible features listed, concierge services, luggage storage, and self parking (surcharge) |
| Known for | Historic cottage accommodations and a quiet, adults-only Old Town setting | Lush garden setting, upscale boutique rooms, and on-site dining/pools |
| Breakfast | Complimentary continental breakfast (Starbucks coffee) in breakfast room | Complimentary cooked-to-order breakfast served daily |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in Old Town a short walk from Duval Street and Old Town landmarks.
Choose Paradise Inn if you prioritize an immediate Old Town, walkable base in historic surroundings.
The Gardens Hotel is centrally located in Key West and a short walk to Duval Street and major Old Town sites.
The Gardens Hotel suits travelers who want central Old Town access plus more on-site hotel services.
Rooms at Paradise Inn are cottage-style suites and Bahamian-style houses with outdoor living spaces.
Pick Paradise Inn for cottage layouts and private outdoor room features in a small-property setting.
The Gardens Hotel offers a range of room types from historic rooms to multi-bedroom cottages and suites.
The Gardens is better if you want a variety of traditional hotel room types, including larger cottages and suites.
Paradise Inn does not have a named on-site restaurant or bar but does provide breakfast and evening refreshments to guests.
If you want on-site dining options, Paradise Inn relies on nearby Old Town eateries rather than an in-house restaurant.
The Gardens Hotel includes an on-site restaurant plus multiple bars and a poolside bar.
The Gardens is the clear choice for guests wanting hotel-style dining and bar options on site.
Paradise Inn’s signature amenity is its palm-shaded outdoor pool and separate hot tub set in garden grounds.
Choose Paradise Inn for a calm pool patio experience integrated with the inn’s gardens and cottages.
The Gardens Hotel features multiple outdoor pools and garden spaces that define the property’s character.
The Gardens works well if you want more on-site pool variety and garden lounging options.
Paradise Inn focuses on low-key wellness options and a quiet adult-only evening atmosphere.
Paradise Inn is for travelers who prefer subdued, adult-focused relaxation rather than a busy spa scene.
The Gardens Hotel lists spa/beauty services nearby or on-property and a livelier on-site bar scene.
The Gardens is preferable if you want more structured wellness options and evening social spaces on site.

Paradise Inn — strictly adults-only cottages, a quiet pool and hot tub, and an inn-sized guest list.

The Gardens Hotel — multiple pools, on-site restaurant and bars, concierge services, and more hotel-style amenities.

Paradise Inn — restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style houses give a small-property historic character.

The Gardens Hotel — landscaped tropical gardens, terraces, and multiple outdoor pools frame the property experience.
Paradise Inn Key West is strictly adults-only (minimum check-in age 21). The Gardens Hotel’s supplier copy contains mixed signals about age policy; check the property directly before booking.
The Gardens Hotel has an on-site restaurant and multiple bars. Paradise Inn does not have a named on-site restaurant or bar but provides a complimentary continental breakfast and an evening wine & cheese offering.
The Gardens Hotel has two outdoor pools and a poolside bar. Paradise Inn has one palm-shaded pool with a fountain feature plus a separate hot tub.
Yes. Both properties are located in Key West’s Old Town within short walking distance of Duval Street and major attractions such as the Hemingway Home.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·