
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for adults wanting a small, historic Old Town base within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Old Town sights.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an 18-room, adults-only boutique inn in Old Town made up of restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style suites; read this if you want a small, historic, walkable base for exploring Duval Street and Old Town. Parrot Key Hotel & Villas is a larger, resort-style property on Key West’s northside with villas, multiple pools, and a more secluded atmosphere; read this if you prefer more on-site space, pools, and villa-style rooms.
Updated · about 1.8 miles (2.9 km) apart

Best for adults wanting a small, historic Old Town base within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Old Town sights.

Best for travelers who want villa-style rooms, more on-site pools and services, and easy access to a beach shuttle and marina activities.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if you want a quiet, adults-only, historic-property experience in the middle of Old Town with a single palm-shaded pool, morning continental breakfast, and easy walking access to Duval Street and nearby landmarks.
When Parrot Key Hotel & Villas wins: choose Parrot Key if you want a larger resort footprint with villa and suite options, multiple outdoor pools, a poolside bar and restaurant options, recreational gear and beach shuttle, and on-site concierge services for water activities.
Bottom line: Paradise Inn is the pick for a compact, adult-focused Old Town stay with historic character; Parrot Key is the pick for a more traditional resort stay with space, pools, and villa-style room choices away from the Duval Street core.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Parrot Key Hotel & Villas |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic, adults-only inn set in restored cottages and gardens | Tropical resort-style hotel and villas with lush grounds and a secluded feel |
| Location | Old Town, a short walk to Duval Street and Old Town landmarks | Northside Key West; about 1.8 miles from Old Town core (beach shuttle available) |
| Size | About 18 rooms (small, intimate property) | 148 individually decorated guestrooms and suites (large resort) |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only (minimum check-in age 21; guests 18 and under not permitted) | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | One palm-shaded outdoor pool plus a separate outdoor hot tub | Four outdoor pools, including a poolside bar and pool sun loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and wine & cheese happy hour | On-site options including The Grove Food Truck, bar/lounge, and a poolside bar; cooked-to-order breakfast available (surcharge) |
| Wellness & spa | Small outdoor spa/hot tub; in-room massages on request (no named spa facility) | Fitness facilities listed; no named full-service spa published in supplier listing |
| Known for | Historic cigar-maker cottages, intimate adult-only atmosphere, Old Town walkability | Villas, suites, multiple pools, on-site recreational rentals and beach shuttle |
| Transport & access | Walkable Old Town location; no airport shuttle; on-site parking available (fee) | In Northside; complimentary beach shuttle and valet parking (surcharge) listed |
| Accessibility | No elevator; accessible King Mini Suite and paths noted | Wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); many accessible room types listed |
Paradise Inn sits at 819 Simonton Street in the heart of Old Town, a short walk from Duval Street and several historic sites.
Choose Paradise Inn for immediate Old Town access and short walks to bars, restaurants, and historic sights.
Parrot Key Hotel & Villas sits on Key West’s northside (2801 N Roosevelt Blvd), separate from the Old Town core.
Choose Parrot Key if you prefer a more resort-like property and don’t need immediate Old Town walkability.
Paradise Inn’s rooms are compact suites and named cottages arranged across restored historic buildings.
Expect historic charm, suite-focused layouts, and a small selection of named cottages rather than standard hotel corridors.
Parrot Key offers a wide selection of guestrooms, suites, and multi-bedroom villa options.
Choose Parrot Key for roomy suite and multi-bedroom villa options and many room-type choices.
Paradise Inn does not operate a restaurant or bar; food and drink options are nearby in Old Town.
Paradise Inn suits travelers happy to walk into Old Town for full-service restaurants and nightlife.
Parrot Key lists on-site food and beverage options and poolside service.
Parrot Key works well if you want on-site casual dining and poolside drinks without going into Old Town every night.
Paradise Inn centers on a single palm-shaded outdoor pool and a separate outdoor hot tub.
Choose Paradise Inn if you want a small, tranquil pool patio as part of a boutique stay.
Parrot Key lists multiple outdoor pools and a broad menu of on-site water-recreation options.
Parrot Key is better if multiple pools, on-site water gear, and beach shuttle access matter to you.
Paradise Inn focuses on low-key wellness touches rather than a full spa or nightlife scene.
Paradise Inn is for travelers who prefer quiet evenings and arranging activities off-property.
Parrot Key lists fitness facilities and many on-site activity options but no widely published, named full-service spa in the supplier listing.
Parrot Key offers more on-site activity and fitness options; neither property shows a named, full-service spa in public listings.

Paradise Inn — immediate proximity to Duval Street and historic attractions on foot.

Parrot Key — four outdoor pools, poolside bar, plus on-site rental options and beach shuttle.

Paradise Inn — strictly adults-only with an intimate, historic-cottage setting.

Parrot Key — 148 rooms with many suite and multi-bedroom villa configurations.
Paradise Inn is much closer — it sits in Old Town within a short walk of Duval Street; Parrot Key is on the northside and requires a short ride or bike into the center.
Paradise Inn Key West is adults-only (minimum check-in age 21); Parrot Key Hotel & Villas accepts all ages.
Pick Parrot Key for multiple outdoor pools and a livelier poolside environment; Paradise Inn has a single palm-shaded pool and separate hot tub for a quieter experience.
Neither property’s public listings show a named full-service spa; Paradise Inn offers an outdoor hot tub and in-room massage on request, while Parrot Key lists fitness facilities and many activity options but no named spa in the supplier listing.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·