Paradise Inn Key West vs Nearby Hotels
Considering Paradise Inn Key West but want to compare other hotels nearby? These guides show how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against popular alternatives.
Updated · 19 comparisons
All 19 Paradise Inn Key West Comparisons

Paradise Inn Key West vs Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection
Paradise Inn: adults-only Old Town cottages; Casa Marina: larger oceanfront Curio resort with private beach.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Ocean Key Resort A Noble House Resort
Choose an adults-only cottage stay in Old Town (Paradise Inn) or an upscale waterfront resort at Mallory Square (Ocean Key).
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa
Compare a quiet adults-only Old Town cottage stay with a branded waterfront Hyatt resort near Duval Street.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Pier House Resort & Spa
Compare a quiet adults-only Old Town inn (historic cottages, garden pool) with a waterfront resort (private beach, spa, on-site dining).
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs The Reach Key West, Curio Collection
Paradise Inn Key West: adults-only historic cottages near Duval. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection: beachfront Hilton resort with spa and meeting space.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses
Paradise Inn — adults-only boutique on Simonton; Southernmost Beach Resort — larger beachfront resort near the Southernmost Point.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Margaritaville Beach House Key West
Paradise Inn: adults-only Old Town cottages; Margaritaville Beach House: larger beachfront Margaritaville resort.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Hilton Key West Resort & Marina
Small adults‑only Old Town inn (Paradise Inn) vs branded waterfront marina resort (Hilton Key West Resort & Marina).
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection
Adults-only cottage inn with garden pool vs Autograph Collection hotel on Duval — quiet historic lodging or central full-service stay.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Paradise Inn Key West: adults-only historic cottages in Old Town. The Marker Key West Harbor Resort: modern harbor-front resort with multiple pools and on-site dining.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Parrot Key Hotel & Villas
Paradise Inn: small adults-only Old Town inn; Parrot Key: resort-style villas with multiple pools.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Havana Cabana at Key West
Choose quiet Old Town character at Paradise Inn or a Cuban-flavored resort scene at Havana Cabana—Old Town walkability vs a big pool and on-site dining.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs DoubleTree Resort
Adults-only Old Town boutique inn vs Hilton-branded oceanfront resort — choose intimacy or resort services.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs The Gates Hotel Key West
Compare Paradise Inn Key West (adults-only Old Town cottages) with The Gates Hotel Key West (contemporary New Town hotel with on-site dining).
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Hilton Garden Inn Key West / The Keys Collection
Paradise Inn: adults-only Old Town cottages; Hilton Garden Inn: mainstream New Town hotel with on-site dining and pool.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Eden House
Eden House — long-running Key West inn with 39 individually decorated rooms, pool, hot tub and on-site Mediterranean restaurant Azur.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs The Gardens Hotel
Paradise Inn: adults-only historic cottages, small pool and hot tub; The Gardens Hotel: upscale boutique with two pools, restaurant, and garden grounds in Old Town.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Fairfield
Adults-only Old Town cottages vs a larger Marriott-family hotel with free breakfast and parking.
Compare →
Paradise Inn Key West vs Hampton Inn Key West FL
Paradise Inn: adults-only historic cottages in Old Town; Hampton Inn: Hilton-family waterfront hotel with pool and fitness.
Compare →
Complimentary continental breakfast daily
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge