
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for adults who want a quiet Old Town base within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Old Town sights.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an adults-only, 18-room boutique inn in Old Town made up of restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style suites — read this if you want a quiet, walkable Old Town base. Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites Key West is a 3.5-star Marriott-family hotel in Key West’s New Town — read this if you prefer a familiar chain property with standard amenities, free breakfast, and on-site parking.
Updated

Best for adults who want a quiet Old Town base within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Old Town sights.

Best for travelers who prefer a recognizable Marriott-family hotel with free buffet breakfast, on-site self parking, and a larger selection of accessible room types.
When Paradise Inn wins: choose Paradise Inn Key West if you want an adults-only, small-property stay in historic Old Town within easy walking distance of Duval Street, Hemingway Home, the Key West Lighthouse, and Old Town dining.
When Fairfield wins: choose Fairfield if you want the consistency of a national-brand property with more rooms, accessible-room options, a fitness center, an outdoor pool with wheelchair-accessible access, weekday and weekend complimentary buffet breakfast, and free self parking.
Bottom line: both hotels work as bases in Key West but target different travelers — Paradise Inn for an intimate, adults-only Old Town experience; Fairfield for chain-brand familiarity, more on-site services, and easy parking in New Town.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Fairfield |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Adults-only boutique inn in restored cottages and Bahamian-style houses; intimate, gardened grounds. | Midscale Marriott-family hotel in New Town with straightforward business/travel amenities. |
| Location | 819 Simonton St in Old Town, a block from Duval Street and close to Hemingway Home and Key West Lighthouse. | 3852 North Roosevelt Boulevard in New Town (not Old Town); marketed as within a short drive of Duval Street and beaches. |
| Size & rooms | About 18 rooms and suites (small), many one- and two-bedroom suites, cottages, and named garden cottages. | 133 guestrooms across many accessible and suite types (larger property) including Deluxe and Superior Suite options. |
| Age policy | Adults-only; minimum check-in age 21; guests 18 and younger not permitted. | Welcomes guests of all ages (children under 18 can stay free with parents per supplier notes). |
| Pools & outdoor | Small palm-shaded outdoor pool with fountain feature and a separate outdoor hot tub; pool access included in resort fee. | One outdoor pool with poolside bar and wheelchair-accessible pool; pool listed among onsite amenities. |
| Dining & breakfast | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast (Starbucks coffee) and a wine-and-cheese happy hour by the pool. | Snack bar/deli, one bar/lounge and a poolside bar; complimentary buffet breakfast on weekdays and weekends (hours vary). |
| Wellness & fitness | No fitness center; in-room massage available on request; no named spa facility (small outdoor spa tub present). | Fitness facilities on site and business center; no named luxury spa listed in supplier content. |
| Parking & transport | Limited on-site parking with a daily fee; no airport shuttle. | Free self parking available onsite; preferred airport Key West Intl. (EYW) listed 2.6 km from the hotel. |
| Accessibility & family policy | Adults-only policy; accessible King Mini Suite and wheelchair-accessible path of travel but no elevator. | Multiple accessible room types and wheelchair-accessible pool, registration desk, parking and fitness center. |
| Known for | Historic cottages and an adults-only Old Town atmosphere within walking distance of Duval Street. | Recognizable Marriott-brand reliability, free breakfast, and more conventional on-site services. |
Paradise Inn is in Old Town on Simonton Street, a short walk to Duval Street and several historic sites.
Choose Paradise Inn for direct Old Town access and walking to local sights.
Fairfield sits in New Town (North Roosevelt Boulevard) with easier parking and chain-hotel convenience.
Choose Fairfield if you want easier car parking and a familiar brand base outside Old Town.
Paradise Inn is an 18-room property focused on suites, cottages, and historic character.
Choose Paradise Inn for historic character and cottage-style suites, accepting a very small property footprint.
Fairfield offers a wide range of standard rooms and suites typical of a midscale Marriott-family property.
Choose Fairfield for predictable room formats, multiple accessible options, and more overall inventory.
Paradise Inn does not operate a named on-site restaurant or bar but provides light in-house offerings.
Expect a light in-house breakfast and nearby Old Town dining rather than hotel-run restaurants.
Fairfield has basic on-site dining options plus a bar and poolside drink service.
Choose Fairfield if you want on-site snack and bar options plus a complimentary buffet breakfast.
Paradise Inn centers its outdoor experience on a palm-shaded pool and a separate hot tub.
The pool area is small and intimate — matches the property’s boutique scale and adults-only focus.
Fairfield provides a conventional outdoor pool and poolside service as part of its wider amenity set.
Fairfield’s pool and outdoor services suit travelers who want standard hotel recreational amenities and accessibility.
Paradise Inn is set up for quiet relaxation rather than formal wellness facilities or nightlife.
Expect quiet evenings and informal on-site relaxation rather than a resort spa or hotel nightlife.
Fairfield provides standard hotel services that include fitness and business facilities.
Fairfield fits travelers who want hotel-style wellness and business services plus activity booking help.

Paradise Inn — steps from Duval Street and Old Town historic sites.

Paradise Inn — strictly adults-only with an intimate, quiet property layout.

Fairfield — recognizable Marriott-family name, standardized rooms and services.

Fairfield — free self parking and a complimentary buffet breakfast are included.
Choose Paradise Inn; it sits on Simonton Street in Old Town within easy walking distance of Duval Street and several historic attractions.
No. Paradise Inn is adults-only and requires a minimum check-in age of 21; guests 18 and younger are not permitted to stay.
Yes. Paradise Inn offers a complimentary continental breakfast (Starbucks coffee). Fairfield provides a complimentary buffet breakfast on weekdays and weekends per the supplier listing.
Fairfield has free self parking and multiple wheelchair-accessible features listed; Paradise Inn has limited on-site parking (fee applies) and no elevator.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·