
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for couples and adult travelers who want a small, historic Old Town base and an adults-only atmosphere.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an 18-room, adults-only boutique inn in Old Town for travelers who want historic charm and walking access to Duval Street. Hilton Garden Inn Key West / The Keys Collection is a mainstream, 3.5-star branded hotel in New Town for visitors who prefer a larger property with typical Hilton conveniences.
Updated · about 4 km apart

Best for couples and adult travelers who want a small, historic Old Town base and an adults-only atmosphere.

Best for guests who want a familiar Hilton-brand stay with more rooms, on-site dining options, and standard business/leisure amenities.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if you want an adults-only, intimate Old Town experience within easy walking distance of Duval Street, the Hemingway Home, and much of historic Key West.
When Hilton Garden Inn Key West / The Keys Collection wins: pick the Hilton Garden Inn for a mainstream, full-service hotel with more room types, on-site restaurants, a pool and hot tub, parking options, and a business-friendly layout.
Bottom line: pick Paradise Inn for small-hotel character and central Old Town location; pick Hilton Garden Inn for predictable brand amenities and a larger property footprint in New Town.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Hilton Garden Inn Key West / The Keys Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic, adults-only boutique inn | Mainstream, branded midscale hotel |
| Location | Old Town — 819 Simonton St, a short walk to Duval Street and historic sites | New Town — 3850 N Roosevelt Blvd, near Key West Tropical Forest & Golf Club |
| Size (rooms) | About 18 rooms (small) | 141 guestrooms |
| Who can stay | Adults only (minimum check-in age 21) | All ages allowed |
| Pools & hot tubs | Palm-shaded outdoor pool with fountain feature + separate outdoor hot tub | Outdoor pool and a hot tub; pool cabanas (surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and wine & cheese happy hour | 2 restaurants (The Garden Grille among them), bar/lounge and poolside bar |
| Spa / wellness | No dedicated spa facility; in-room massage available and outdoor spa tub | Not published |
| Accessibility & parking | No elevator; onsite parking (fee) and limited spaces noted | Uncovered self parking (surcharge), wheelchair-accessible paths and rooms |
| Known for | Historic cottages, intimate gardens, adults-only atmosphere | Hilton Garden Inn brand familiarity, larger property with business amenities |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in Old Town, a short walk to Duval Street and several historic sites.
Choose Paradise Inn for immediate Old Town access and easy walking to classic Key West attractions.
Hilton Garden Inn is located on N Roosevelt Blvd in New Town, near the Key West Tropical Forest and the golf club.
Choose the Hilton for a property with more parking and shuttle options away from the Old Town bustle.
Paradise Inn offers one- and two-bedroom suites and named garden cottages set across restored historic buildings.
Expect individually styled, cottage-style rooms with an intimate, Old Town character.
Hilton Garden Inn supplies a wide range of standard Hilton-style rooms and suites.
Expect predictable, functional rooms in many configurations with in-room microwaves/fridges.
Paradise Inn does not operate a named on-site restaurant or bar but provides morning and evening in-house amenities.
Plan to eat off-property at nearby Old Town restaurants or use the inn’s light breakfast and evening offerings.
Hilton Garden Inn has on-site dining and drink options.
The Hilton supports full meals and casual drinks on-site — handy if you prefer not to go into Old Town for each meal.
Paradise Inn centers guest life around a palm-shaded pool and separate outdoor hot tub set in tropical gardens.
Good for guests who prefer a quiet pool patio set among gardens rather than a large resort pool scene.
Hilton Garden Inn provides a standard hotel pool and outdoor amenities.
Choose the Hilton if you want a larger, amenity-forward pool area and poolside food/drink service.
Paradise Inn focuses on low-key relaxation rather than a full wellness program.
Pick Paradise Inn when a relaxed, low-activity stay and quiet evenings matter most.
Hilton Garden Inn includes standard business and fitness conveniences.
Pick the Hilton for fitness options, business services, and a more conventional hotel layout.

Paradise Inn — steps from Duval Street, Hemingway Home, and classic Old Town sights.

Hilton Garden Inn — multiple on-site restaurants, bar, poolside service, and a fitness center.

Paradise Inn — an adults-only policy and small, historic cottages create an intimate atmosphere.

Hilton Garden Inn — Hilton-brand consistency, more rooms, accessible options, and parking/shuttle conveniences.
Paradise Inn — it sits on Simonton Street in Old Town and is within easy walking distance of Duval Street and many historic attractions.
Hilton Garden Inn — it has two restaurants, a bar, and fitness facilities; Paradise Inn has no on-site restaurant and no fitness center.
No. Paradise Inn is strictly adults-only; the minimum check-in age is 21.
Yes; both properties offer on-site parking but expect daily fees at each (Hilton notes uncovered self parking surcharge; Paradise Inn lists a daily parking fee).
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·