
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for travelers who want an adults-only, small-scale Old Town stay with restored cottages, a palm-shaded pool, and easy walkability to Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an 18-room, adults-only boutique inn made up of restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style houses in Old Town; read this if you want a quiet, historic, adult-only Key West base. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa is a 120-room branded waterfront resort with full-service amenities and a central Key West location; read this if you want resort facilities, a spa, and a dockside location near Duval Street.
Updated · about 0.4 km apart

Best for travelers who want an adults-only, small-scale Old Town stay with restored cottages, a palm-shaded pool, and easy walkability to Duval Street.

Best for visitors who prefer a larger, full-service resort with an on-site restaurant (Four Flamingos Key West), a spa, a dock/marina, and a waterfront location steps from Duval Street.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if you want a quiet, adults-only Old Town experience in historic cottages, a small palm-shaded pool and hot tub, complimentary continental breakfast, and a location that feels like a boutique inn rather than a resort.
When Hyatt Centric wins: choose Hyatt Centric if you want resort-style amenities — a full-service spa, a full-service on-site restaurant (Four Flamingos Key West), a dock/marina and water activities, a 24-hour fitness center, and a larger property with meeting space.
Bottom line: both put you within easy reach of Duval Street and Old Town attractions. Pick Paradise Inn for intimate, adults-only historic charm and a quiet pool patio; pick Hyatt Centric for waterfront resort conveniences, on-site dining and spa services.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, adults-only boutique inn in restored cottages and garden grounds | Larger branded waterfront resort with resort-style amenities and meeting space |
| Location | 819 Simonton Street — Old Town, a short walk to Duval Street and Old Town sights | 601 Front St — waterfront, steps from Duval Street and Mallory Square |
| Size (rooms) | About 18 rooms | 120 rooms |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only; minimum check-in age 21 | All ages allowed (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Palm-shaded outdoor pool and separate outdoor hot tub on a patio | Outdoor pool (number listed: 1) with poolside bar and loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and a wine & cheese happy hour | On-site restaurant Four Flamingos Key West (ocean-view) plus bar and poolside bar; room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | No dedicated named spa; in-room massage available and a small outdoor spa/hot tub | Full-service spa offering massages, body treatments, facials and a 24-hour fitness center |
| Known for | Historic cottages, adult-only atmosphere, complimentary continental breakfast and wine & cheese happy hour | Waterfront location, branded Hyatt service, marina/dock and on-site Four Flamingos restaurant |
| Accessibility & services | No elevator; accessible King Mini Suite and wheelchair-accessible path of travel noted | Elevator, accessible rooms and extensive wheelchair-accessible public spaces/services |
| Parking & transport | On-site parking available (daily fee noted in some sources; limited spaces) | Self parking (surcharge), valet for wheelchair-equipped vehicle, close to Key West Intl. Airport |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in Old Town, one block from Duval Street and within easy walking reach of Old Town sights.
Pick Paradise Inn to stay immersed in Old Town’s historic, walkable streets and a quieter cottage setting.
Hyatt Centric sits on Front Street at the water’s edge and places you directly on the waterfront a short stroll from Duval Street.
Choose Hyatt Centric if you want waterfront proximity, easy marina access and being steps from key waterfront attractions.
Rooms at Paradise Inn are arranged across restored cottages and Bahamian-style houses; many include porches, balconies or sundecks.
Paradise Inn is for travelers who prefer quirky, historic rooms and outdoor private spaces over standardized hotel rooms.
Hyatt Centric offers a wide mix of standardized room types, many with partial ocean or ocean views and private furnished balconies.
Hyatt Centric fits travelers who want predictable, accessible rooms with options for ocean views and more hotel-style consistency.
Paradise Inn does not operate a restaurant or bar onsite but includes a complimentary continental breakfast and a daily wine & cheese happy hour.
If on-site restaurants and bars matter, Paradise Inn relies on nearby Old Town dining rather than its own outlets.
Hyatt Centric provides on-site dining with ocean views and a bar, plus room service during limited hours.
Hyatt Centric is the better pick for guests who want to dine and drink on property, especially waterfront meals.
Paradise Inn centers its outdoor social life on a palm-shaded pool patio and a separate outdoor hot tub.
The inn’s pool is small, private and suited to guests seeking a relaxed, low-key poolside experience.
Hyatt Centric has a resort-style outdoor pool, poolside services and direct waterfront access via its dock/marina.
Hyatt Centric is the better fit for guests who want a more active poolside scene plus easy access to water activities from the hotel.
Paradise Inn’s wellness options focus on relaxed offerings—a small outdoor spa tub and in-room massages on request.
Choose Paradise Inn if you want a low-key wellness approach and to head into Old Town for after-dark activity.
Hyatt Centric offers a full-service spa, fitness facilities and organized onsite wellness options.
Hyatt Centric suits guests seeking hotel spa treatments, a gym and on-site evening dining or late-night options.

Paradise Inn — adults-only cottages, intimate garden grounds and a quiet pool patio close to Duval Street.

Hyatt Centric — waterfront location with dock access and easy links to boat tours and marina activities.

Hyatt Centric — Four Flamingos Key West, a poolside bar, room service and full-service spa.

Paradise Inn — small size, historic cottages and an adults-only policy make it well suited to couples and quiet getaways.
Hyatt Centric is on Front Street at the waterfront and offers dock/marina access; Paradise Inn is inland on Simonton Street and a short walk from waterfront spots.
Pick Paradise Inn — it is strictly adults-only with a minimum check-in age of 21. Hyatt Centric accepts guests of all ages.
Hyatt Centric has a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities. Paradise Inn offers a small outdoor spa tub and in-room massage by request but no full spa or fitness center.
No — Paradise Inn does not operate a restaurant or bar on site; it provides a complimentary continental breakfast and a wine & cheese happy hour and relies on nearby Old Town restaurants for meals.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·