
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for couples seeking a quiet, intimate adults-only inn steps from Old Town sights and evening strolls on Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an 18-room, adults-only boutique inn in Old Town for travelers who want a quiet, historic-Key West stay near Duval Street. Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses is a larger, beach-oriented resort complex near the island’s southern edge for guests who want on-site pools, spa services, and easy beach access.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for couples seeking a quiet, intimate adults-only inn steps from Old Town sights and evening strolls on Duval Street.

Best for travelers who want a bigger resort with beach access, multiple room choices, on-site pool(s) and spa-style services.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if you want an adults-only, small-property experience in restored historic cottages with a single palm-shaded pool, complimentary continental breakfast, and an intimate Old Town location a short walk from Duval Street.
When Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses wins: choose Southernmost Beach Resort if you prefer a beachfront resort complex with a wider set of room types, outdoor pool(s), on-site spa/massage services, and more full-service hotel amenities and tour/ticket help.
Bottom line: both properties deliver classic Old Town Key West character but to different audiences — Paradise Inn for a small, adult-focused boutique stay; Southernmost Beach Resort for a larger, beach-oriented resort experience with more on-site facilities.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic adults-only inn in restored cottages | Large Southernmost-area resort complex with beach-oriented branding |
| Location (Old Town / landmark access) | Simonton Street, a block from Duval Street and Old Town attractions | 1319 Duval Street near the Southernmost Point and beach access |
| Size | 18 rooms (adults-only) | Many rooms across guesthouses and suites (multiple room types listed) |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only (minimum check-in age 21) | All ages accepted |
| Pools / hot tubs | One palm-shaded outdoor pool with a fountain feature and a separate outdoor hot tub | Outdoor swimming pool(s) and poolside bar listed |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and wine-and-cheese happy hour are provided | On-site restaurants and bar(s) listed in supplier facts |
| Spa & wellness | No dedicated spa facility; in-room massage available and a small outdoor spa tub | Spa/massage services and spa/sauna listed as on-site amenities |
| Known for | Quiet, historic cottages and an adults-only atmosphere close to Duval Street | Beach-oriented resort experience carrying the Southernmost name |
| Concierge / tours | Concierge/tour assistance for snorkeling, sunset sails and day trips | |
| Accessibility & services | No elevator; accessible King Mini Suite and accessible path of travel noted | Wheelchair accessible rooms and facilities; elevators listed |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in Old Town a short walk from Duval Street and historic sites.
Take Paradise Inn for the most central Old Town, walkable experience in historic surroundings.
Southernmost Beach Resort emphasizes its southern-edge location with beach access near the Southernmost Point.
Take Southernmost Beach Resort if proximity to the island’s southern waterfront and beach time matter more than a tiny boutique setting.
Paradise Inn’s 18 rooms and cottages are arranged in historic cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style houses.
Choose Paradise Inn for restored historic rooms and a limited, curated room roster tailored to adults.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses offers a broad set of room types across its complex.
Choose Southernmost Beach Resort for more room variety and larger-suite or residence options.
Paradise Inn does not operate a full restaurant or bar but includes morning continental breakfast and an evening poolside happy hour.
Paradise Inn is for travelers who plan to eat out in Old Town rather than rely on hotel dining.
Southernmost Beach Resort lists restaurants and bar(s) among on-site amenities.
Southernmost suits guests who want convenient on-site dining and relaxed poolside drink options.
Paradise Inn offers a single palm-shaded outdoor pool (with fountain feature) and a separate outdoor hot tub on the patio.
Paradise Inn’s pool/hot tub arrangement suits guests seeking a quiet poolside atmosphere rather than multiple resort pools.
Southernmost Beach Resort lists outdoor swimming pools plus direct beach access for guests.
Southernmost is better if you want beach time and more extensive poolside facilities on-site.
Paradise Inn focuses on low-key relaxation: a small outdoor spa tub and in-room massages on request.
Choose Paradise Inn for low-key relaxation with the option to step into Old Town nightlife when desired.
Southernmost Beach Resort lists a spa, massage and fitness amenities among its services.
Southernmost caters to guests who want on-site spa treatments, fitness and resort-style activity options.

Adults-only rooms, small property and an intimate garden-and-pool setting near Duval Street.

Direct beach access plus resort pools and poolside bar for daytime relaxation.

Many room categories from economy to multi-bedroom residences and adult-only Avalon rooms.

Central Simonton Street location places you within easy walking distance of Old Town attractions and Duval Street.
Paradise Inn is adults-only with a 21+ check-in minimum; Southernmost Beach Resort accepts all ages.
Yes — the supplier listing highlights beach access as one of the resort’s features.
Southernmost lists on-site restaurants and bar(s); Paradise Inn does not operate a restaurant or bar but offers continental breakfast and a poolside wine-and-cheese hour.
Paradise Inn is very central on Simonton Street a block from Duval Street; Southernmost is in the Southernmost area, closer to the Southernmost Point and beach.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·