
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for adults seeking a small, intimate Old Town base within easy walking distance of bars, galleries, and historic sights.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an 18-room, adults-only boutique inn in Old Town made up of restored cigar-maker cottages — read this if you want a small, quiet, historic stay within easy walking distance of Duval Street. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection is an upscale, Hilton-affiliated beachfront resort at the southern end of Key West — read this if you want resort amenities (private beach, pool, spa) and branded services.
Updated

Best for adults seeking a small, intimate Old Town base within easy walking distance of bars, galleries, and historic sights.

Best for travelers who prefer a full-service beachfront resort with a private beach, outdoor pool, spa services, and on-site meeting space.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if you want a quiet, adults-only boutique stay in historic cottages a short walk from Duval Street and Old Town attractions, with a small palm-shaded pool and complimentary continental breakfast.
When The Reach Key West, Curio Collection wins: choose The Reach for beachfront access, a larger resort footprint (150 rooms), a full-service spa, poolside bar and on-site restaurant, and Hilton Curio amenities and meeting spaces.
Bottom line: pick Paradise Inn for small-scale, adults-only Old Town character and easy walking access to nightlife and sights; pick The Reach for a resort-style beach experience and branded services on Key West’s waterfront.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | The Reach Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic, adults-only boutique inn | Upscale, branded beachfront resort |
| Location | Old Town/Simonton Street — a block from Duval Street | Southern Old Town beachfront on Simonton Street near Southernmost Point |
| Size | About 18 rooms (small) | About 150 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only (minimum check-in age 21; no one 18 or younger permitted) | All ages welcome (not an adults-only property) |
| Pools & beach | One palm-shaded outdoor pool and a separate outdoor hot tub | One outdoor pool and access to a private beach |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and wine & cheese happy hour | On-site restaurant (Four Marlins), poolside bar and room service (limited hours); buffet breakfast available for a fee |
| Spa & wellness | No dedicated spa facility; in-room massage available on request; no fitness center | Full-service spa with treatment rooms and a fitness center |
| Meetings & events | No verifiable meeting or ballroom space; gatherings discouraged (no bachelor/bachelorette parties) | Conference and event space — 4 meeting rooms and ~4,700 sq ft of event space |
| Brand & recognition | Independent, historic boutique inn | Hilton Curio Collection — part of a major hotel brand |
| Accessibility & services | No elevator; on-site parking (fee); bike rentals and concierge tour help | Wheelchair-accessible features, valet parking (fee), multilingual staff and concierge |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in Old Town, a block from Duval Street and close to historic sites.
Choose Paradise Inn if you want an Old Town walkable base and neighborhood feel.
The Reach sits farther toward the southern end of Old Town on Simonton Street with private beach access.
Choose The Reach if a beachfront location and private beach access matter more than being steps from Duval’s busiest blocks.
Paradise Inn’s rooms are cottage-style suites and small standalone units set across garden grounds.
Expect compact, character-filled rooms with cottage layout rather than high-rise hotel corridors.
The Reach offers a broad range of studio and suite room types, several ocean- or resort-view options, and accessible rooms.
Choose The Reach for a wider variety of room types and ocean-view/resort-view options under a branded program.
Paradise Inn does not operate a named on-site restaurant; food and drink are simple and guest-focused.
Good choice if you plan to eat off-property at nearby Old Town restaurants or want light, included breakfast and evening refreshment.
The Reach features on-site dining and bars and offers room service during limited hours.
Pick The Reach if you want on-site dining options and poolside drinks without leaving the property.
Paradise Inn’s signature amenity is its palm-shaded pool patio and separate hot tub in a garden setting.
Paradise Inn offers a quiet pool patio that suits an adults-only, low-key stay.
The Reach’s signature draw is its private beach plus outdoor pool and resort-style pool area.
The Reach is the clear pick when beach access and resort poolside service are priorities.
Paradise Inn focuses on peaceful adult-only evenings in garden and pool areas rather than nightlife on site.
Expect low-key evenings and an emphasis on relaxation rather than on-site nightlife or fitness facilities.
The Reach provides a full-service spa and meeting/event facilities alongside resort leisure options.
Pick The Reach when you want spa treatments, fitness, or event facilities together with beachfront leisure.

Paradise Inn — intimate, historic cottages, adults-only policy, and walking distance to Duval Street.

The Reach — private beach, poolside bar, on-site restaurant and a full-service spa.

The Reach — Hilton Curio branding, multiple meeting rooms and sizable event space.

Paradise Inn — restored cigar-maker cottages, garden setting, small property scale and adult-only atmosphere.
Both are in Old Town and walkable to many attractions, but Paradise Inn is a block from Duval Street and places you closer to the busiest Old Town blocks.
Paradise Inn includes a complimentary continental breakfast. The Reach offers buffet breakfast for a fee (approximately USD 25–35 per person).
Choose The Reach; it has private beach access. Paradise Inn does not have a private beach.
The Reach has multiple meeting rooms and ~4,700 sq ft of event space; Paradise Inn does not have verifiable, named meeting or ballroom facilities and discourages large, raucous group events.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·