
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for travelers who want a small, adults-only Old Town hideaway steps from Duval Street with garden cottages and a quiet pool patio.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an adults-only, 18-room boutique inn in Old Town with garden cottages, a palm-shaded pool, and a quiet, walkable Old Town location. Ocean Key Resort - A Noble House Resort is an upscale, 100-room waterfront resort at the Mallory Square end of Duval Street for travelers who want direct harbor/ocean access and resort-style services.
Updated · about 0.4 km apart

Best for travelers who want a small, adults-only Old Town hideaway steps from Duval Street with garden cottages and a quiet pool patio.

Best for travelers who want an upscale, waterfront Key West stay with a larger resort footprint, spa services, and immediate Mallory Square access.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if you want an adults-only, small-property experience in historic cottages, a palm-shaded pool and hot tub, complimentary continental breakfast, and a quieter, garden-focused setting within easy walking distance of Old Town sights.
When Ocean Key Resort wins: choose Ocean Key if you prefer being literally on the waterfront beside Mallory Square and Duval Street, want a full-service spa, resort-style pool and multiple on-site dining/drink options, and concierge services for marina and water-sport activities.
Bottom line: both put you in the heart of Key West, but they serve different moods — Paradise Inn is intimate and garden-centered for adult couples or solo travelers; Ocean Key is a larger, waterfront resort for guests who want resort amenities and immediate access to Mallory Square’s waterfront scene.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Ocean Key Resort A Noble House Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small adults-only boutique inn set in restored cottages and garden grounds | Upscale waterfront resort with larger scale services and public spaces |
| Location | 819 Simonton St., a block from Duval Street in Old Town | Zero Duval St., at the Mallory Square end of Duval Street and the waterfront |
| Size (rooms) | About 18 rooms | 100 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | Adults-only; minimum check-in age 21 | Open to all ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Palm-shaded outdoor pool with fountain feature and separate hot tub | One outdoor pool with poolside bar and free cabanas |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and evening wine & cheese happy hour | Two restaurants and three bars/lounges (room service available during limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | No named spa facility; in-room massage available and an outdoor spa/hot tub | Full-service spa and 24-hour fitness center |
| Known for | Historic cigar-maker cottages, intimate garden setting, adults-only policy | Waterfront location at Mallory Square, resort amenities and concierge services |
| On-site activities & services | Bicycle rentals, concierge-arranged snorkeling/sailing excursions, free Wi‑Fi | Concierge, bicycle rentals, water sports nearby, valet parking (surcharge), limo/town car service |
| Accessibility & family policy | No elevator; accessible King Mini Suite and wheelchair path; adults-only policy | Wheelchair-accessible features and accessible pool; not adults-only |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in Old Town — a short, easy walk to Duval Street and Old Town attractions.
Choose Paradise Inn for a quiet Old Town base a block from Duval in a garden setting.
Ocean Key is positioned at Zero Duval Street, right at Mallory Square on the waterfront.
Choose Ocean Key to be on the water and in the middle of the Mallory Square/Duval Street action.
Rooms are housed in restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style houses with many offering outdoor living spaces.
Expect small-scale, characterful rooms with outdoor space rather than large standardized hotel rooms.
Ocean Key offers 100 individually decorated guestrooms, many with private balconies and ocean or harbor views.
Ocean Key gives more room-type variety and waterfront-view options for a resort-scale stay.
Paradise Inn does not operate a full restaurant or bar; it provides a complimentary continental breakfast and an evening wine & cheese offering.
If you want on-site dining, plan to walk out to nearby Old Town restaurants; Paradise Inn keeps food offerings simple and small-scale.
Ocean Key operates multiple on-site dining and drinking outlets plus room service (during limited hours).
Ocean Key suits guests who prefer multiple on-site dining and bar options without leaving the resort.
Paradise Inn’s outdoor facilities focus on a palm-shaded pool with a fountain feature and a separate hot tub in a garden setting.
Paradise Inn’s pool area is small, private, and integrated with the gardens — good for relaxed downtime.
Ocean Key provides a resort-style outdoor pool beside the waterfront, with poolside service and cabanas.
Ocean Key’s pool and waterfront setting are more active and resort-oriented, with on-site service and marina access.
Paradise Inn emphasizes a low-key wellness approach with in-room massage and a small hot tub; nightlife is the nearby Old Town scene rather than on-property.
Expect quiet, adult-focused evenings and modest wellness options at Paradise Inn.
Ocean Key has a full-service spa, a 24-hour fitness facility, and immediate access to waterfront nightlife at Mallory Square.
Ocean Key is better suited if you want a spa and immediate access to the livelier waterfront nightlife.

Paradise Inn — small property, adults-only policy, restored cottages, garden pool and hot tub.

Ocean Key — located at Zero Duval St. on the waterfront, steps from Mallory Square and Duval Street.

Ocean Key — two restaurants, three bars/lounges, poolside bar, full-service spa, and concierge services.

Paradise Inn — restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style houses across landscaped grounds.
Paradise Inn Key West is strictly adults-only with a minimum check-in age of 21. Ocean Key is not adults-only.
Ocean Key is right at Mallory Square on the waterfront; Paradise Inn is a short walk away in Old Town's garden-lined streets.
Ocean Key has a full-service spa and a 24-hour fitness facility. Paradise Inn offers in-room massage and a small outdoor hot tub but no named spa or fitness center.
Ocean Key offers multiple on-site dining and bar options; Paradise Inn does not operate a restaurant or bar and relies on nearby Old Town restaurants.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·