
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for travelers who want an adults-only, small historic-inn experience within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Old Town sights.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an 18-room, adults-only boutique inn in Old Town for travelers who want compact historic cottages and an Old Town walking base. The Gates Hotel Key West is a 4-star contemporary lifestyle hotel in New Town for guests considering modern, branded-style lodging and easy access to the island’s northern entry area.
Updated · about 3.1 miles (5.0 km) apart

Best for travelers who want an adults-only, small historic-inn experience within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Old Town sights.

Best for guests seeking a larger, modern hotel with more on-site dining, a fitness center and contemporary amenities near Key West’s northern corridor.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if you want an adults-only, small-property stay in Old Town with historic cottage character, a palm-shaded pool and easy pedestrian access to Duval Street and Old Town landmarks.
When The Gates Hotel Key West wins: pick The Gates if you prefer a bigger, contemporary hotel with multiple on-site restaurants/cafe, a fitness center, bicycle rentals, and clearer accessibility features in the New Town area.
Bottom line: both offer stylish alternatives to large beach resorts — Paradise Inn is a quiet, adults-only Old Town hideaway; The Gates is a modern lifestyle-brand option with more on-site services and dining near the island’s entry area.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | The Gates Hotel Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, historic cottage-style boutique inn, intimate adults-only setting | Contemporary, lifestyle-branded midrise with modern public spaces |
| Location | Old Town, a block from Duval Street and close to Hemingway Home and the lighthouse | New Town / north Key West, near Key West Tropical Forest and Botanical Garden |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms/suites | 100 rooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only; minimum check-in age 21 | All ages allowed (not adults-only) |
| Pools & hot tubs | Palm-shaded outdoor pool with fountain feature and a separate outdoor hot tub | Outdoor pool (one) with poolside bar and cabana options; pool hours published by property |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar (complimentary continental breakfast and evening wine & cheese offered) | Two restaurants plus a coffee shop/cafe, bar/lounge and a poolside bar |
| Wellness / spa | No named spa; in-room massage available and small outdoor spa tub | Health/beauty spa listed as 'nearby'; on-site fitness center |
| Known for | Historic cottages, tropical gardens, intimate adults-only atmosphere | Contemporary design, branded amenities, on-site dining and accessibility features |
| Airport proximity | About 2 miles (≈3.2 km) from Key West International Airport | About 2.9 km (1.8 mi) from Key West International Airport (supplier listing) |
| Accessibility & services | No elevator; wheelchair-accessible King Mini Suite and accessible paths reported | Elevator, multiple wheelchair-accessible services and paths listed |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in historic Old Town, a short walk from Duval Street and several well-known historic sites.
Choose Paradise Inn if you want an Old Town, walk-everywhere base in a historic cottage setting.
The Gates Hotel is in Key West’s New Town/entry area, positioned for guests arriving to the island and those who prefer modern hotel neighborhoods.
Choose The Gates if you prefer modern hotel convenience near the island’s entry area rather than Old Town’s compact historic streets.
Rooms at Paradise Inn are arranged across restored cottages and Bahamian-style houses with one- and two-bedroom options and several named cottages.
Expect cottage-style layouts and suites with outdoor living spaces rather than standardized hotel room design.
The Gates offers air-conditioned, contemporary rooms (supplier lists Double Room among types) with typical hotel conveniences.
Rooms are contemporary and standardized, with more hotel-style room inventory and on-site services.
Paradise Inn does not operate a restaurant or bar but provides a complimentary continental breakfast and an evening wine & cheese hour.
Plan to eat off-property for full meals; the inn supplies light complementary morning and early-evening offerings.
The Gates has multiple on-site dining options and a bar, which makes eating on property simpler.
The Gates is better if you want a hotel with on-site restaurant and bar choices.
Paradise Inn centers much of its guest relaxation around a palm-shaded outdoor pool and a separate hot tub on the tropical patio.
The pool and hot tub provide a quiet, small-property relaxation area in a garden setting.
The Gates offers an outdoor pool with poolside bar service and cabana options for guests.
The Gates’ pool scene is more of a hotel-style social amenity with on-site service options.
Paradise Inn focuses on relaxed, adults-only evenings around its garden, pool and wine-hour rather than active nightlife on site.
Expect low-key, intimate evenings and spa services arranged to the room rather than a hotel wellness center.
The Gates lists evening entertainment and a fitness center among its on-site amenities to support a livelier stay.
The Gates suits travelers who want on-site activity options, a fitness facility and easier access to arranged entertainment.

Paradise Inn — choose it for restored cigar-maker cottages, gardens and immediate access to Old Town’s sights and Duval Street.

The Gates — pick it if you want multiple on-site restaurants/cafe, a bar and a more hotel-style set of services.

Paradise Inn — the property enforces an adults-only policy and curates a quieter, intimate atmosphere.

The Gates — the supplier listing highlights an elevator and numerous wheelchair-accessible features across the property.
Paradise Inn — it sits in Old Town about a block from Duval Street and within short walking distance of many historic sites.
The Gates — it offers two restaurants, a coffee shop/cafe, a bar and a fitness center; Paradise Inn does not have on-site restaurants.
Paradise Inn is adults-only (minimum check-in age 21). The Gates is not adults-only.
It depends: Paradise Inn has a small, palm-shaded pool and a separate hot tub in a garden setting for a quieter experience; The Gates has a single outdoor pool with a poolside bar and cabana options for a more social hotel pool scene.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·