
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for couples or adults who want a small, quiet Old Town base within easy walking distance of Duval Street and historic sights.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an 18-room, adults-only boutique inn in Old Town for travelers who want a quiet, historic-feeling stay steps from Duval Street. Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is a branded, full-service marina resort on Stock/Key West with broad mainstream recognition for guests who want marina access, many pools, and resort facilities.
Updated

Best for couples or adults who want a small, quiet Old Town base within easy walking distance of Duval Street and historic sights.

Best for travelers who prefer a recognized hotel brand with marina access, many pools, on-site boat activities and a larger resort footprint.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: Choose Paradise Inn if you want an adults-only, small-property experience in restored cigar‑maker cottages with a palm-shaded pool, hot tub, complimentary continental breakfast and immediate Old Town walkability.
When Hilton Key West Resort & Marina wins: Pick the Hilton if you want marina access, multiple outdoor pools (listed as 6), on-site boating and watersports options, a 24-hour fitness center and a larger set of resort services and rental options.
Bottom line: Paradise Inn is a quiet, historic boutique pick for adult travelers focused on Old Town; Hilton is a mainstream marina resort with more facilities and activity options. Your choice depends on whether you value small‑property charm and strict adults‑only policy (Paradise Inn) or brand conveniences, watersports and resort-scale amenities (Hilton).
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Hilton Key West Resort & Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Quiet adults-only boutique in historic cottages and gardens | Branded marina resort with mainstream, family-friendly services |
| Location | 819 Simonton Street — in Old Town, a block from Duval Street and historic sites | 5950 Peninsular Avenue — next to Stock Island Yacht Club & Marina; resort set on the waterfront |
| Size | Small — 18 rooms across cottage buildings | Large — 175 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | Adults-only; minimum check-in age 21 | All ages allowed; not adults-only |
| Pools / hot tubs | One palm‑shaded outdoor pool + separate outdoor hot tub | Six outdoor pools listed; poolside bar(s) |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and evening wine & cheese | One on-site restaurant and a coffee shop/cafe; room service limited hours |
| Spa / wellness | No named spa facility; in-room massage available and outdoor hot tub | No named spa published in supplier listing |
| Signature amenities | Historic cigar‑maker cottages, garden patios, complimentary continental breakfast and bicycles | Marina on site, boat tours, motorized watercraft, bicycle rentals and 24-hour fitness |
| Accessibility & services | No elevator; accessible King Mini Suite and wheelchair path of travel noted; concierge help with tours | Wheelchair accessible path and parking; multilingual staff, concierge, 24‑hour front desk |
| Parking | On-site parking available; daily parking fee reported | Self parking available (surcharge) |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in Old Town within an easy walk of Duval Street, the Hemingway Home and the Key West Lighthouse.
If you want to be in the heart of Old Town and walk to most sights, Paradise Inn is the more centrally located choice.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is located next to Stock Island Yacht Club & Marina and sits on the waterfront on Peninsular Avenue.
Choose the Hilton if waterfront access, boating and marina services matter more than immediate Old Town walkability.
Paradise Inn’s roughly 18 rooms and suites are spread across low‑rise historic cottages and Bahamian‑style houses, many with outdoor living spaces.
Rooms emphasize historic character, outdoor space and a small‑property layout rather than a uniform, modern hotel room experience.
Hilton offers 175 guestrooms in a conventional resort layout with many room categories and partial/ocean view balconies.
Hilton provides standard hotel room variety and modern in‑room features across many categories including suites and accessible rooms.
Paradise Inn does not operate a named on‑site restaurant or bar; it serves a complimentary continental breakfast and offers a nightly wine & cheese poolside offering.
Expect minimal on‑site dining — most meals are at nearby Old Town restaurants off property.
Hilton lists one on‑site restaurant plus a coffee shop/cafe, with room service during limited hours and cooked‑to‑order breakfast available for a fee.
Hilton supports more on‑site dining options for breakfasts, lunches and drinks compared with Paradise Inn.
Paradise Inn centers around a single palm‑shaded outdoor pool with fountain feature and a separate outdoor hot tub on a tropical patio.
The inn’s pool and hot tub are for quiet relaxation rather than a resort‑scale activity program.
Hilton lists six outdoor pools and a marina offering a range of on‑site water activities and boat tours.
Hilton is set up for guests who want varied pool choices and on‑site boating and water‑activity options.
Paradise Inn keeps wellness low‑key: an outdoor spa tub and optional in‑room massages rather than a full spa or fitness center.
Expect quiet, low‑service wellness and restrained on‑site nightlife suitable for adult couples wanting calm evenings.
Hilton offers a 24‑hour fitness facility and resort‑style pool nightlife options via its bars and pool areas.
Hilton supports a broader wellness and activity program, including a 24‑hour gym and more lively pool/bar options.

Paradise Inn — steps from Duval Street and many historic sites.

Hilton — marina on site, boat tours and motorized watercraft options.

Paradise Inn — strict adults‑only policy and a low‑key pool/hot tub setting.

Hilton — many pools (6 listed), 24‑hour fitness and on‑site dining and rental options.
Paradise Inn — it is located on Simonton Street in Old Town, a block from Duval Street and close to historic attractions.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina — it has a marina on site and lists motor boating, fishing, kayaking, boat tours and personal watercraft among its amenities.
Paradise Inn is adults‑only with a minimum check‑in age of 21. Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is open to all ages.
Paradise Inn offers an outdoor hot tub and in‑room massages; no named spa facility is published. The Hilton supplier listing does not publish a named spa.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·