
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for travelers who want an adults-only, cottage-centered Old Town stay with a small, quiet property and garden setting.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an adults-only boutique inn made up of restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style rooms in Old Town; read this if you want a quiet, adult-focused base a block from Duval Street. Eden House is a long-running independent Key West inn with about 39 individually decorated rooms, a pool and an on-site restaurant; read this if you want characterful, full-service lodging within easy Old Town walking distance.
Updated · about 0.5 km apart

Best for travelers who want an adults-only, cottage-centered Old Town stay with a small, quiet property and garden setting.

Best for travelers who want a long-running, characterful independent inn with on-site dining and a larger selection of room types.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if an adults-only atmosphere, historic cottage layout, and a small property tailored to couples or adults are your priorities. It’s focused on a relaxed Old Town experience with a palm-shaded pool and evening wine-and-cheese hour.
When Eden House wins: pick Eden House if you want more room-type variety, an on-site restaurant (Azur) and bar, and slightly larger property services (concierge, computer station, shuttle options). It’s a good choice if you prefer an all-ages inn with more on-site facilities.
Bottom line: both are independent boutique inns in Old Town Key West within easy walking distance of Duval Street; choose Paradise Inn for an adults-only, cottage-style quiet stay, and Eden House for a more traditional small-hotel experience with on-site dining and more room options.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Eden House |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small adults-only inn set across restored cottages and Bahamian-style suites | Long-running independent Art Deco/Old Town inn with a laid-back local character |
| Location (Old Town) | 819 Simonton St — about a block from Duval Street and close to Hemingway Home | 1015 Fleming St — in Key West Historic District, within a 15-minute walk of Duval Street |
| Size (rooms) | 18 rooms (cottage-centered layout) | 39 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | Adults-only; minimum check-in age 21 | Welcomes guests of all ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools & hot tubs | Palm-shaded outdoor pool and separate outdoor hot tub | |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar (complimentary continental breakfast, wine & cheese happy hour) | On-site Mediterranean restaurant Azur, coffee shop/cafe and a poolside bar |
| Wellness & extras | In-room massage on request; no dedicated spa facility; no fitness center | Hot tub, nearby health/beauty spa options listed (no named on-site spa) |
| Known for | Historic cigar-maker cottages, adults-only atmosphere, garden setting | Individually decorated rooms, longstanding boutique reputation, on-site dining |
| Accessibility & services | Accessible King Mini Suite and accessible path of travel; no elevator | Wheelchair accessible – no (listing); 24-hour front desk, concierge, multilingual staff |
| Parking & transport notes | On-site parking available (limited), substantial daily parking fee noted elsewhere; no airport shuttle | Limited on-site parking; ferry/airport shuttle available for surcharge per listing |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in the heart of Old Town, a short walk from Duval Street and major historic sites.
Choose Paradise Inn for the most compact Old Town, cottage-style location and immediate access to Duval Street.
Eden House is located in the Key West Historic District and is within a comfortable walk of Duval Street and the Historic Seaport.
Choose Eden House if you want a full-service inn still within Old Town walking range but with slightly larger on-site facilities.
Paradise Inn's accommodations are composed of restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style rooms and suites.
Pick Paradise Inn for cottage-style suites and patios with an emphasis on historic character.
Eden House has 39 individually decorated guestrooms across multiple room categories.
Choose Eden House if you want more room-type choices and standard in-room conveniences like microwaves and minibars.
Paradise Inn does not operate a formal on-site restaurant or bar but provides in-house breakfast and evening refreshments.
Paradise Inn is best if you plan to eat out in Old Town and use the inn’s simple morning and evening refreshments.
Eden House offers on-site dining options including a Mediterranean restaurant and a coffee shop/cafe.
Eden House is better if you value an on-site restaurant and poolside bar for meals and drinks.
Paradise Inn centers much of its guest experience on a palm-shaded outdoor pool and a separate outdoor hot tub.
Paradise Inn emphasizes a compact, gardened pool patio as the property's social hub for adults.
Eden House features an outdoor pool and hot tub with poolside seating and a poolside bar.
Eden House offers a conventional small-hotel pool area with a staffed poolside bar and more on-site amenities nearby.
Paradise Inn offers low-key wellness options and a quiet evening atmosphere tailored to adults.
Paradise Inn suits travelers seeking a quiet, adult-focused stay rather than a lively nightlife hub on property.
Eden House provides basic wellness options and access to nearby nightlife and activities.
Eden House fits travelers who want easy access to Old Town nightlife plus basic on-site recreational amenities.

Paradise Inn — strict adults-only policy, small cottage layout, and a quiet garden pool area.

Eden House — on-site Mediterranean restaurant Azur, coffee shop, and a poolside bar.

Eden House — about 39 individually decorated rooms across many room types, from studios to suites.

Paradise Inn — restored cigar-maker cottages and Bahamian-style houses create a historic Old Town feel.
Paradise Inn Key West is adults-only with a minimum check-in age of 21; Eden House welcomes guests of all ages.
Eden House has an on-site Mediterranean restaurant (Azur), a coffee shop/cafe and a poolside bar; Paradise Inn does not operate a formal on-site restaurant or bar.
Yes. Both are in Old Town Key West within easy walking distance of Duval Street; they sit roughly a few blocks apart (about 0.5 km).
Eden House is larger with about 39 rooms and more front-desk/concierge services; Paradise Inn is smaller (about 18 rooms) and focused on a cottage-style, adults-only experience.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·