
Paradise Inn Key West
Best for couples who want a small, quiet, historic Old Town stay steps from Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Paradise Inn Key West is an adults-only boutique inn in Old Town made up of restored cigar-maker cottages and small suites; read this if you want a quiet, historic, walkable Old Town base. Margaritaville Beach House Key West is a 4-star, branded beach-house-style resort on South Roosevelt Boulevard; read this if you want a larger, beachfront property with a resort-style program and recognizable Margaritaville vibe.
Updated · about 2.1 km apart

Best for couples who want a small, quiet, historic Old Town stay steps from Duval Street.

Best for travelers who want beachfront access, resort amenities, and a recognizable Margaritaville atmosphere.
When Paradise Inn Key West wins: choose Paradise Inn if you want an adults-only, low-key boutique stay in the heart of Old Town where most historic sites and Duval Street are an easy walk. Its small size, cottages, complimentary continental breakfast, and evening wine-and-cheese hour favor intimate, relaxed pacing over resort activity.
When Margaritaville Beach House Key West wins: pick Margaritaville for a larger, full-service beach-hotel experience—beach access, an outdoor pool, a hot tub, on-site restaurant and poolside bar, a 24-hour fitness center, meeting rooms, and complimentary airport shuttle on request. It's better if you want on-site dining, organized services, and easy beach access.
Bottom line: Paradise Inn is a small, adults-only Old Town hideaway focused on historic character and walkability; Margaritaville Beach House is a bigger, family-friendly (not adults-only) beachfront resort with broader on-site amenities and a branded, casual beach-house identity.
| Category | Paradise Inn Key West | Margaritaville Beach House Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Quiet, adults-only boutique in restored cottages | Lively branded beach-house resort with resort services |
| Location | 819 Simonton Street — Old Town, block from Duval Street and historic sites | 2001 South Roosevelt Blvd — by the ocean, near Smathers Beach |
| Size | About 18 rooms (small) | 186 rooms (large) |
| Age policy | Adults-only property; minimum check-in age 21 | All-ages property (not adults-only) |
| Pools & hot tubs | Palm-shaded outdoor pool with fountain feature + separate outdoor hot tub | Outdoor pool and a hot tub; pool cabanas (surcharge) and poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant or bar; complimentary continental breakfast and wine & cheese happy hour | On-site restaurant, bar/lounge, poolside bar, and limited room service |
| Wellness & fitness | No fitness center; in-room massage available on request; spa tub only | 24-hour fitness facilities; spa nearby (not necessarily on-site) and on-property wellness options listed |
| Accessibility & services | Concierge, bike rentals, free Wi‑Fi, no elevator across cottages | Wheelchair-accessible paths/rooms, elevator, business center, multilingual staff, free airport shuttle (on request) |
| Known for | Historic charm, Old Town walkability, adults-only atmosphere | Branded Margaritaville experience with beachfront access and resort amenities |
| Nearby highlights | Duval Street, Hemingway Home, Key West Lighthouse, South Beach within walking distance | Smathers Beach, Higgs Beach, Fort East Martello Museum; roughly a short drive to Old Town |
Paradise Inn sits on Simonton Street in Old Town within easy walking distance of Duval Street and several historic sites.
Choose Paradise Inn for immediate Old Town access and short walks to the island’s main historic sights.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West sits on South Roosevelt Boulevard by the ocean and near Smathers Beach.
Choose Margaritaville for direct beach access and a spot on the island’s southern shore, with easier arrival service to the airport.
Paradise Inn’s 18 rooms and named cottages are small in number and emphasize historic character and outdoor spaces.
Expect individually styled, cottage-style rooms and suites with a historic feel and outdoor living spaces.
Margaritaville has a wide range of room types across 186 air-conditioned rooms, from standard King rooms to multi-bedroom suites with resort or ocean views.
Expect predictable, modern hotel rooms with many layout options and accessible offerings across a large property.
Paradise Inn does not operate a restaurant or bar on site; it provides a complimentary continental breakfast and a nightly wine & cheese hour.
If you prefer on-site restaurants, Paradise Inn is not the right fit; it’s intended for guests who plan to dine off property in Old Town.
Margaritaville offers on-site dining options and poolside drinks within a resort setting.
Margaritaville suits travelers who want the convenience of on-property meals and casual poolside service.
Paradise Inn centers its outdoor social life around a palm-shaded pool with a fountain feature and a separate outdoor hot tub.
This is a quiet pool setting designed for relaxation after Old Town outings rather than beachside resort activity.
Margaritaville places guests by the ocean with an outdoor pool and hot tub plus poolside amenities.
Margaritaville is better if you plan to spend time at the beach and want a resort-style pool scene.
Paradise Inn is intentionally low-key in the evening with no on-site nightlife; spa options are limited to in-room massages and the small spa tub.
Pick Paradise Inn for quiet evenings and Old Town nightlife a short walk away, not for on-site nightlife or a spa complex.
Margaritaville offers more full-service hotel amenities including a 24-hour fitness center and hotel services aimed at a resort-stay experience.
Margaritaville is the choice when you want on-site fitness and a broader set of guest services during your stay.

Paradise Inn — small cottages, Old Town address, immediate walkability to Duval Street and historic sites.

Margaritaville Beach House — beachfront location, larger pool scene, restaurant and poolside bar, and resort services.

Paradise Inn — strictly adults-only with minimum check-in age and a quiet, mature atmosphere.

Margaritaville Beach House — elevators, accessible rooms and paths, business center, and complimentary airport shuttle on request.
Paradise Inn is in Old Town on Simonton Street and is a short walk to Duval Street, Hemingway Home, and other historic sites.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West is located on South Roosevelt Boulevard and is by the ocean near Smathers Beach; Paradise Inn is in Old Town and a short walk from South Beach but not beachfront.
Paradise Inn Key West is adults-only with a minimum check-in age of 21. Margaritaville Beach House Key West is not adults-only.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West offers a complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle (available on request). Paradise Inn does not provide airport shuttle service.
Explore how Paradise Inn Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·